What you can do when an rcd trips
An rcd usually trips because of a faulty appliance or wiring. The best chance you have of resetting it is to unplug (switching off isn’t always the same*) as many appliances as you can. Problems with the wiring are another cause – like damage from nails, screws, water ingress and rats chewing through them. If you have an electric hob, oven, shower and extractor fan; switching the relevant isolator off may help get your power back on.
Why does an rcd to trip? Diagnostics you can do yourself for nothing
1. First identify what circuits the rcd switching off is protecting. If your consumer unit has one it maybe (see below) protecting all circuits. With two residual protective devices; each one monitors half the installation (to help minimize inconvenience). If you have an RCBO (this is an rcd and overload protective device in one unit) it protects just one circuit and therefore the easiest to troubleshoot.
If you don’t know what an rcd or rcbo looks like you can see examples below.
How to identify an rcd device (and if it is in the tripped state)
Split load (dual rcd) consumer unit (probably the most common modern type installed)
Split board, single rcd.
Single rcd consumer unit
This is what a full rcbo consumer unit looks like
2. Turn all electrical equipment in the property off (to prevent damage to televisions, computers and other sensitive electronic devices). Switch the rcd off by the lever, or by pressing the test button. Now make a list of what no longer works that should. The list will tell you what circuits and appliances could be causing the problem.
3. If you believe the socket circuit is to blame; unplug all the appliances – not just the easy ones, or the old appliances. Everything. Sometimes customers say things like: “i didn’t unplug the washing machine because its difficult to move”. Or, “i didn’t unplug the kettle because it is only a few months old.” Well, new things can be faulty. I’m happy to attend, but if i unplug your washing machine and the fault clears, you have a call out fee and the cost of a new washing machine! And turning the switch off might not be enough – *many socket outlets are single pole which means just the live is switched off leaving the neutral connected (the rcd monitors both). So unplug. Yes, it can be a pain, but you want the power back on right? With as much unplugged as you can – see if the rcd will now reset. If it will, connect the appliances back one at a time. If you believe to have found a faulty appliance, try it by itself. Two appliances with a high combined earth leak can be enough to trip an RCD although sometimes not by themselves. This can be a red herring when diagnosing rcd faults. I was asked to troubleshoot an rcd trip in Cardiff recently where the customer bought a new microwave. They bought a new one because every time they switched it on the rcd went off. Unfortunately they had the same problem with the new one and then called me. The problem was with the wiring inside the socket the microwave was plugged in to.
What you have done so far may be time consuming but a valuable exercise. Even if you don’t find the cause of the tripping – write down what you have done and show it to the electrician so they don’t waste time (and your money) doing the same. Any suspected appliances that you can do without; leave disconnected for a few hours or days if necessary to help confirm. Sometimes appliances unknowingly faulty lived in a home without rcd protection move to a new one and cause tripping. Portable appliance testing should confirm the fault, but that’s with the help and test equipment from an electrician . Users of the equipment would understandably assume a problem with the wiring or electrical installation.
4. If you think your electric shower is causing a problem; try turning the isolator off. A shower isolator removes the power in the same way unplugging a faulty kettle from its socket would. If the rcd resets this would suggest a fault with the shower.
5. If the RCD trips are infrequent (the trickiest to diagnose), make a note of when it happens. Could it be:
- An extractor fan in a guest bathroom?
- A security light that no longer works?
- The oven reaches a certain temperature?
- An outdoor light fitting affected by the weather?
- A rarely used appliance?
- If you wake up in the morning with the rcd in the off position – think what might be happening when you are asleep. Do you have an immersion heater that powers on at midnight and off at 6am? Do you have an heating in a greenhouse that comes on? Do you have security lights that may have become damaged and trying to come on?
Referred to as ‘nuisance tripping’ by many. In a large percentage of tests electricians confirm rcds do actually work as designed. Residual current devices detect earth leakage (electrical current leaking somewhere it shouldn’t be). They remove the power if the live and neutral go out of balance protecting users from electrocution and buildings from fire. Most rcds tripping under fault conditions will be between 20 and 30 milliseconds – faster than you can blink! ‘Nuisance’ arose because re-wireable fuses and miniature circuit breakers didn’t trip at all! Designed to protect the cables if overload occurred. Fuses and circuit breakers offer no protection from a person coming into contact with a live conductor. RCDs help prevent electrical related injuries and fire. They are a big part of the wiring regulations electricians adhere to.
If you have tried everything listed above to no avail don’t worry. Perhaps the trip is too random or not local to one area. Don’t despair, what you have done will have saved the electrician you do call out time and enable them to continue with more involved troubleshooting.
Notes that will help you (and the electrician if you contact one) track the cause.
1. The first time the tripping started.
2. If any work has been carried out on the property. New lights, sockets, shelves, flooring, kitchen units can all cause tripping if the wiring has been disturbed unknowingly by a screw, nail or not terminated correctly.
3. If you have fitted any additional electrical appliances or had any repaired.
4. Previous unresolved electrical problems.
5. If you have experienced power cuts.
6. If you have power supplying outdoor fixtures or buildings.
Time to call an electrician: what they can do to resolve unwanted tripping :
This instrument reveals the amount of current leaking. In the photo above a small amount (1.8ma) is normal. rcds state 30ma tripping current although most trip closer to 25ma to ensure they disconnect in the necessary time frame. If no leak (or rather nothing near the tripping threshold) is present the rcd can be ramp tested. This is when we can check its tripping exactly like the manufacturer designed it to like in the video below:
If the circuit protection tests OK disconnected from the installation, further testing will be necessary. An rcd/rcbo that does not trip within the necessary threshold will need replacing. If the residual current isn’t close it’s time to troubleshoot.
I’ve covered appliances although that is only one aspect of residual current. Problems with wiring inside accessories (like light switches and socket outlets), cable buried inside the wall, above the ceiling, or inside plastic trunking can cause tripping . Have you fitted shelves, a picture frame or a mirror? Could a screw or nail have damaged the wires inside the wall? You can expect buried cables if an accessory is close-by (like a socket or light fitting). Cables can be present without any sign of an accessory and often damaged unintentionally when something is fitted to the wall.
If you ask any electrician in Cardiff they will tell you rats love chewing through cables. So if you have cabling clipped along an outside wall or under decking – is it possible they have become damaged by rodents? It’s not just outdoors cables are at risk unfortunately. Rats can climb and sometimes cables inside the loft space can become damaged if you have had a problem with them. It was common practice at one time to get cables from one floor to another by taking a brick out at both levels. The cables passed down the cavity of the walls as a route from first floor to ground floor. We don’t install cables like this anymore, but that doesn’t mean you can rule it out until it has been checked.
When i am troubleshooting i usually make a list of the circuit descriptions from within the consumer unit and measure the leakage across each one. With the amount of appliances in use today the amount of residual leakage can be close to the tripping threshold with not one particular fault. Sometimes its a little leak on one circuit, bit more on another, bit higher on the circuit supplying items outdoors. When you add them all together it’s not far off the amount the rcd is designed to trip leaving you without power. Some items will leak small bits of current through their design. Its not dangerous to the user, but in large premises (or, and) with lots of appliances it can be a problem. It is for this reason, my usual advice when replacing a consumer unit, or troubleshooting problematic rcd faults is to fit a full rcbo consumer unit (see photo above). With this configuration you are allowed the same amount of residual current per circuit opposed to half the installation on a dual rcd or the entire premises when one rcd is protecting everything.
I have listed the results of a recent installation experiencing random tripping. With everything disconnected from the rcd it passed test after test. I had no doubt the rcd device itself was not the problem. It was an accumulation of residual current:
|Circuit description||Leakage (in milliamps)|
|Sockets Ground floor||2.2|
|Sockets First Floor||2.9|
|Garden lighting and pond equipment||2.4|
The total leak for the installation was 18.4 milliamps at the time of test. Because one rcd was protecting the whole installation it was getting close to the trip threshold with not one particular problem that could have been (easily) removed on the day. The easiest part of the installation to break down further with a high overall reading was the socket circuit on the first floor. This is what i found:
|Appliance||Leakage (in milliamps)|
I found 2.9ma leak at the consumer unit and 2.2 whilst on the first floor. The missing 0.7 could be due to the wiring supplying the socket outlets, something intermittent or something i could not find attached to the installation. My point being the bigger the installation with the more appliances means more natural residual earth leakage which rcds were designed to protect against.
If you have followed my advice and still unable to find the cause of your rcd tripping then get in touch so i can help you (if you live in the Cardiff and Vale area). The cost to resolve it will depend on the amount of time to find the cause and then what is involved to rectify it.